The First Loaf: How I Fell in Love with Sourdough

The pandemic gave me the gift of time. What sourdough taught me about patience, freshness, and real food.

I’ll never forget my first loaf – flat, awkward, and overly dusted with flour. It wasn’t the prettiest loaf, but when I cut into it and took a bite, I was blown away by the taste and texture.

In those next months of baking sourdough, something changed with my relationship to food. I realized that I’d gone my whole life not knowing what real bread was supposed to taste like, until I made it myself. This was the start of my love of making foods the slow and traditional way.

The starter

Like half of America in 2020, I became curious about sourdough bread. What was this bubbly looking thing called starter, and how could something like that cause my bread dough to “naturally” rise?

In the beginning, I attempted to make my own starter. 10 days in, I had gone through multiple feedings, and cycled through mixtures which were bubbly, then flat, sour smelling, then gag-inducing stinky. Being disheartened by my lack of success, I swallowed my pride and went to my local bakery to purchase some of theirs.

The moment things clicked

My local bakery’s starter acted completely different from my own attempts. I’d feed the bakery starter, and just given some time, it would start forming tiny bubbles, which slowly got bigger, and the mixture would grow and rise. It was as if it was truly alive.

The crazier thing was, the starter smelled incredible. I’d never smelled this kind of complex scent before – slightly alcoholic, pleasantly yeasty, and most surprisingly, sweet.

This strong starter propelled me forwards in my baking journey. I became obsessed with learning the art of sourdough, hours spent on Instagram replaying videos of people mixing the dough, doing coil folds, shaping a risen dough, and more. I asked myself many questions, like what were the signs of a perfectly proofed dough, what are the techniques for building strength in your shaggy dough, how deep should I score to get the optimal oven spring. This is how I came to be self taught in the art of making sourdough.

Learning to make sourdough is a process, with many ups and downs, and many failures. Never compare your initial experiences learning about sourdough baking to someone else. It helps to find a good teacher, but otherwise, stay motivated, persist, and you are well on your way to making delicious bread!

What sourdough taught me about real food

Freshly baked sourdough bread was nothing like the Wonder bread I’d grown up eating, or even the more “artisanal” loaves that I’d bought from the grocery store. Homemade sourdough was perfectly golden and crisp on the outside – that characteristic hard shell and crunch that a sourdough boule has. And, the inside was fluffy, tender, and beautifully bouncy.

Real food tends to be homemade. And real food takes time. The best things in life cannot be rushed. You need to spend the time feeding your starter to keep it healthy. You need to give your dough the 5+ hours its needs to bulk ferment. Ideally but optionally you let the dough rest in the fridge overnight for a cold proof, allowing the flavors of your bread to further develop.

Looking back, sourdough was never just about bread for me. It was my introduction to a different way of cooking and eating – one rooted in patience, attention, and respect for the process. It taught me that when food is made slowly and from scratch, it doesn’t just taste better; it changes how you understand what food can be. And once you’ve experienced that, it’s hard to go back.

Wholesomely Jane offers small-group, hands-on cooking classes in San Francisco. See upcoming classes.